Dirty Three - Cinder (2LP)

Ah, "Cinder" by Dirty Three – now that's an album that invites you to sit down, take a deep breath, and immerse yourself in its intricate soundscapes. Released in 2005, this album marks a distinctive point in the band’s evolution, showcasing a slightly different approach compared to their previous works. Dirty Three, known for their emotive and often improvisational style, consists of the talented trio Warren Ellis (violin), Mick Turner (guitar), and Jim White (drums). Each member brings a unique flavor to the table, creating a blend that's both haunting and beautiful.

What sets "Cinder" apart from other Dirty Three albums is its brevity in tracks. Unlike their typically sprawling compositions, the tracks on "Cinder" are more concise, with none running over five minutes. This might suggest a more accessible approach, but fear not – the album loses none of the trio’s characteristic depth and intensity. It’s like they’ve distilled their usual stormy seas into a series of vivid snapshots, each piece offering a glimpse into a vast, emotional landscape.

The album kicks off with "Ever Since," a track that sets the tone with its melancholic violin lines and sparse, effective percussion. It’s a classic Dirty Three opener: introspective, a bit melancholic, but deeply engaging. As we move through the album, tracks like "She Passed Through" and "Amy" showcase the band’s ability to convey profound emotion through minimalistic arrangements. The violin, in particular, sings with a voice that’s both raw and sublime, weaving through the guitar and drums with an almost narrative quality.

One of the standout tracks is "Doris," which encapsulates the band's knack for dynamic contrast. Starting off quietly, it builds into a crescendo that feels like a cathartic release of pent-up emotions. It’s a powerful moment on the album and a testament to the trio’s mastery of musical storytelling.

Production-wise, "Cinder" is meticulously crafted. The sound is clean yet retains the raw, live feel that Dirty Three is known for. This balance ensures that the emotional heft of the music is never lost under overly polished production. The album was recorded at Electrical Audio in Chicago with the help of engineer Steve Albini, known for his work with Nirvana and Pixies. Albini’s hands-off approach to recording suits Dirty Three perfectly, allowing the natural dynamics of the music to come through unfiltered.

Interestingly, "Cinder" also includes two tracks with vocals – a rarity for the band. Both "Great Waves" and "Last Dance" feature guest vocalists, with Chan Marshall (Cat Power) lending her haunting voice to "Great Waves." Her contribution adds a different texture to the album, complementing the instrumental tracks with her distinctive tone.

Critically, "Cinder" was well-received. Reviewers praised the album for its emotional depth and refined execution. Publications like Pitchfork and AllMusic highlighted the band’s ability to evolve their sound without losing the essence of what makes them unique. The album didn’t just resonate with critics; it also connected with fans who appreciate the band’s unorthodox approach to post-rock and instrumental music.

In terms of cultural significance, "Cinder" stands as a testament to Dirty Three’s enduring influence in the post-rock genre. Their music transcends typical genre constraints, offering a sonic experience that’s as thought-provoking as it is emotive. The album also underscores the band’s global appeal, having garnered a dedicated following across different continents, all drawn to their compelling fusion of rock, folk, and classical elements.

In conclusion, "Cinder" by Dirty Three is not just an album; it’s an emotional journey. It’s a showcase of how powerful music can be when stripped down to its raw, emotional core. For anyone looking to explore the depths of instrumental music, "Cinder" is a must-listen – a beautifully melancholic, profoundly moving piece of art that continues to resonate years after its release.