Metallica & San Francisco Symphony - S&M2 (4LP)

When Metallica and the San Francisco Symphony first joined forces for the iconic S&M concert in 1999, it was a groundbreaking moment that fused heavy metal with orchestral music in a way that had never been done before. Fast forward to 2019, and the band returned to this ambitious collaboration with S&M2, a live album that captures the magic of their second performance with the symphony, held at the Chase Center in San Francisco. This album not only serves as a celebration of Metallica's legacy but also showcases the evolution of their sound and the enduring power of orchestral arrangements in rock music.

S&M2 is a thrilling experience from start to finish, featuring a setlist that spans Metallica's extensive catalog, including classics like "Master of Puppets," "Enter Sandman," and "Nothing Else Matters." The addition of the San Francisco Symphony, conducted by the legendary Michael Tilson Thomas, elevates these tracks to new heights. The orchestral arrangements breathe fresh life into the familiar riffs and melodies, creating a rich tapestry of sound that enhances the emotional weight of the music. The symphony's strings and brass sections intertwine seamlessly with Metallica's heavy guitar work, resulting in a dynamic interplay that is both powerful and poignant.

One of the standout moments on the album is the performance of "The Call of Ktulu," a track that originally appeared on their 1984 album, Ride the Lightning. The orchestral arrangement adds a haunting depth to the instrumental piece, transforming it into a cinematic experience that captures the listener's imagination. Similarly, the rendition of "All Within My Hands" showcases the band’s willingness to experiment, as they incorporate a more delicate, nuanced approach that highlights James Hetfield's vocals and the symphony's lush harmonies.

The production quality of S&M2 is impeccable, capturing the energy of the live performance while ensuring that every instrument is clearly defined in the mix. The album was recorded during two nights of performances in September 2019, and the excitement of the live audience is palpable, adding an extra layer of intensity to the listening experience. The album also features a few new arrangements, including a reimagined version of "Moth Into Flame," which benefits from the orchestral backdrop, making it feel even more grand and expansive.

Critics have praised S&M2 for its ambitious scope and the seamless integration of Metallica's heavy sound with the symphonic elements. Publications like Rolling Stone and Pitchfork have highlighted how the album not only appeals to die-hard Metallica fans but also introduces the band's music to a broader audience who may appreciate the orchestral interpretations. The collaboration has been described as a testament to Metallica's versatility and willingness to push boundaries, proving that their music can transcend genres and resonate with diverse listeners.

In interviews, band members have expressed their excitement about revisiting this unique collaboration. Lars Ulrich, the band's drummer, noted how the experience of performing with the symphony felt like a homecoming, and how the energy of the crowd and the orchestra created an unforgettable atmosphere. The synergy between the musicians is evident throughout the album, as they feed off each other's energy, creating a performance that feels both spontaneous and meticulously crafted.

S&M2 is not just a live album; it’s a celebration of Metallica's journey and their ability to innovate while staying true to their roots. The album serves as a reminder of the band's impact on the music world and their willingness to explore new artistic avenues. For fans of Metallica, S&M2 is a must-have addition to their collection, while for newcomers, it offers a compelling entry point into the band's extensive discography. This album is a testament to the power of collaboration and the enduring legacy of Metallica, proving that even after decades in the industry, they continue to push the envelope and redefine what is possible in music.